Extrinsic and intrinsic factors acting as barriers or facilitators in nurses’ implementation of clinical practice guidelines: a mixed-method systematic review Nurses’ implementation of guidelines.

Main Article Content

Chiara Gallione https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1334-4374
Michela Barisone https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4224-8779
Antonella Molon
Moreno Pavani
Cristina Torgano
Erika Bassi https://orcid.org/0000-0001-6031-1271
Alberto Dal Molin https://orcid.org/0000-0003-2263-1340

Keywords

clinical practice guideline, adherence, guideline, barrier, advanced practice nursing, mixed-method review, systematic review

Abstract

Background and aim of the work: Greater evaluations are needed to identify barriers or facilitators in nurses’ guidelines adherence. The current review aims to explore extrinsic and intrinsic factors impacting nurses’ compliance.


Methods: Mixed-method systematic review with a convergent approach, following the PRISMA checklist and the JBI Mixed Methods Review Methodological Guidance was conducted. MEDLINE, Embase, CINAHL were systematically searched, to find studies published between 2010 and 2021, including qualitative, quantitative or mixed-methods articles.


Results: Sixty studies were included, and the major findings were analysed by aggregating them in two main themes: intrinsic and extrinsic factors. The intrinsic factors were: a) knowledge and skills; b) attitudes of health personnel; c) sense of belonging towards guidelines. The extrinsic factors were: a) organizational and environmental factors; b) workload; c) guidelines structure; d) patients and caregivers’ attitude.


Conclusions: The included studies report lack of resources, among environmental factors, as the main barrier perceived. Nurses, who are at the forefront in addressing the direct application of knowledge and skills to ensure patient safety, have a higher perception of this kind of barriers than other healthcare personnel. Potential facilitators emerged in the review are positive feedback and reinforcements at the workplace, either from the members of the team or from the leaders. Moreover, the level of active participation of the patient and caregiver could have a positive impact on nurses’ guidelines adherence. Guidelines implementation remains a complex process, resulting in a strong recommendation to support health policymakers and nursing leaders in implementing continuing education programs.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.
Abstract 79 | PDF Downloads 63

References

1. Graham R, Mancher M, Miller Wolman D, Greenfield S and Steinberg E. Clinical practice guidelines we can trust, IOM, Ed, Institute of Medicine (US) Committee on Standards for Developing Trustworthy Clinical Practice Guidelines, 2011;
2. Francke A, Smit M, de Veer A, Mistiaen P. Factors influencing the implementation of clinical guidelines for health care professionals: a systematic meta-review. BMC Med Inform Decis Mak 2008; 8:38.
3. Lugtenberg M, Zegers-van Schaick J, Westert G and Burgers J. Why don't physicians adhere to guideline recommendations in practice? An analysis of barriers among Dutch general practitioners. Implement Sci 2009; 4:54.
4. Keiffer M. Utilization of Clinical Practice Guidelines: Barriers and Facilitators, Nurs Clin North Am 2015; 50(2):327-345.
5. Ciro Correa V, Lugo-Agudelo L, Aguirre-Acevedo D. et al. Individual, health system, and contextual barriers and facilitators for the implementation of clinical practice guidelines: a systematic metareview. Health Res Policy Syst 2020; 18:74.
6. Arts D, Voncken A, Medlock S, Abu-Hanna A, van Weert H. Reasons for intentional guideline non-adherence: A systematic review. Int J Med Inform 2016; 89: 55-62.
7. Spoon D, Rietbergen T, Huis A, et al. Implementation strategies used to implement nursing guidelines in daily practice: A systematic review. Int J Nurs Stud 2020; 111:103748.
8. Michie S, van Stralen M, West R. The behaviour change wheel: A new method for characterising and designing behaviour change interventions. Implement Sci 2011; 6:42.
9. Ryan R, Deci E. Self-determination theory and the facilitation of intrinsic motivation, social development, and well-being. Am Psychol 2000; 55: 68-78.
10. Berdud M, Cabasés J, Nieto J. Incentives and intrinsic motivation in healthcare. Gac Sanit 2016; 30(6):408–414.
11. Gaddis G, Greenwald P, Huckson S. Toward improved implementation of evidence-based clinical algorithms: clinical practice guidelines, clinical decision rules, and clinical pathways. Acad Emerg Med 2007; 14 (11): 1015-1022.
12. Jun J, Kovner C, Witkoski Stimpfel A. Barriers and facilitators of nurses’ use of clinical practice guidelines: An integrative review. Int J Nurs Stud 2016; 60:54-68.
13. Hong Q, Pluye P, Bujold M, Wassef M. Convergent and sequential synthesis designs: implications for conducting and reporting systematic reviews of qualitative and quantitative evidence. Syst Rev 2017; 6:61.
14. Pearson A, White H, Bath-Hextall F, Salmond S, Apostolo J, Kirkpatrick P. A mixed-methods approach to systematic reviews. Int J Evid Based Healthc 2015; 13(3):121-131.
15. Stern C, Lizarondo L, Carrier J. et al. Methodological guidance for the conduct of mixed methods systematic reviews. JBI Evid Synth 2020; 18(10):2108-2118.
16. Moher D, Liberati A, Tetzlaff J, Altman D, PRISMA Group. Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses: The PRISMA Statement. BMJ 2009;339:b2535
17. Cohen J. Coefficient of Agreement for Nominal Scales. Educ Psychol Meas 1960; 20(1):37-46.
18. Hong Q, Fàbregues S, Bartlett G et al. The Mixed Methods Appraisal Tool (MMAT) version 2018 for information professionals and researchers. Educ Inf 2018; 34(4):285 – 291.
19. Hong Q, Pluye P, Fàbregues S et al. Improving the content validity of the mixed methods appraisal tool: a modified e-Delphi study. J Clin Epidemiol 2019; 111:49-59.e1
20. Cabana M, Rand C, Powe N, Wu A, Wilson M, Abboud P, & Rubin H. Why don't physicians follow clinical practice guidelines? A framework for improvement. JAMA. 1999; 282(15):1458-65.
21. Landis J and Koch G. The Measurement of Observer Agreement for Categorical Data. Biometrics 1977; 33(1):159-74.
22. Bayuo J, Munn Z, Campbell J. Assessment and management of burn pain at the Komfo Anokye Teaching Hospital: a best practice implementation project. JBI Database System Rev Implement Rep 2017; 15(9):2398–2418.
23. Lai X, Huang Z, Chen C, Stephenson M. Delirium screening in patients in a palliative care ward: a best practice implementation project. JBI Database System Rev Implement Rep 2019; 17(3):429-441.
24. Lu Q, Ng H, Xie H. Translating the evidence for emergency equipment and supplies into practice among healthcare providers in a tertiary mental health institution: a best practice implementation project. JBI Database System Rev Implement Rep 2015; 13(4):295-308.
25. Kowitt B, Jefferson J, Mermel L. Factors Associated with Hand Hygiene Compliance at a Tertiary Care Teaching Hospital. Infect Control Hosp Epidemiol 2013; 34(11):1146-1152.
26. Lin F, Gillespie B, Chaboyer W et al. Preventing surgical site infections: Facilitators and barriers to nurses' adherence to clinical practice guidelines-A qualitative study. J Clin Nurs 2019; 28(9-10):1643-1652.
27. Senanayake H, Patabendige M, Ramachandran R. Experience with a context-specific modified WHO safe childbirth checklist at two tertiary care settings in Sri Lanka. BMC Pregnancy Childbirth 2018;18(1):411.
28. Damush T, Miech E, Sico J et al. Barriers and facilitators to provide quality TIA care in the Veterans Healthcare Administration. Neurology 2017; 12;89(24):2422-2430.
29. Jho H, Kim Y, Kong K et al. Knowledge, practices, and perceived barriers regarding cancer pain management among physicians and nurses in Korea: a nationwide multicenter survey. PLoS One 2014; 9(8):e105900.
30. Van de Steeg L, Langelaan M, Ijkema R, Nugus P, Wagner C. Improving delirium care for hospitalized older patients. A qualitative study identifying barriers to guideline adherence. J Eval Clin Pract 2014; 20(6):813-9.
31. Løyland B, Wilmont S, Cohen B, Larson E. Hand-hygiene practices and observed barriers in pediatric long-term care facilities in the New York metropolitan area. Int J Qual Health Care 2016; 28(1):74-80.
32. Hilton S, Sheppard J and Hemsley B. Feasibility of implementing oral health guidelines in residential care settings: views of nursing staff and residential care workers. Appl Nurs Res 2016; 30:194-203.
33. Trogrlic' Z, Ista E, Ponssen H et al. Attitudes, knowledge and practices concerning delirium: a survey among intensive care unit professionals. Nurs Crit Care 2017; 22(3):133-140.
34. Rodrigues D, Domingues R. Management of syphilis in pregnancy: Knowledge and practices of health care providers and barriers to the control of disease in Teresina, Brazil. Int J Health Plann Manage 2017; 33(2):329-344.
35. Avedissian T, Honein-AbouHaidar G, Dumit N, Richa N. Anaphylaxis management: a survey of school and day care nurses in Lebanon. BMJ Paediatr Open 2018; 2(1):e000260.
36. Tomaszek L, Dezbska G. Knowledge, compliance with good clinical practices and barriers to effective control of postoperative pain among nurses from hospitals with and without a “Hospital without Pain” certificate. J Clin Nurs 2018; 27:1641–1652.
37. Rodríguez Aparicio S, Guitard Sein-Echaluce M, Palomar Martínez M. Barreras y facilitadores en la adherencia al core bundle para prevenir complicaciones asociadas a dispositivos de acceso vascular. Metas Enferm 2019; 22(1):14-23.
38. Cato K, Hyun S, Bakken S. Response to a Mobile Health Decision Support System for Screening and Management of Tobacco Use. Oncol Nurs Forum 2014; 41(2), 145–152.
39. Meurer W, Majersik J, Frederiksen S, Kade A, Sandretto A, Scott P. Provider perceptions of barriers to the emergency use of tPA for Acute Ischemic Stroke: A qualitative study. BMC Emerg Med 2011; 11:5.
40. Arzimanoglou A, Lagae L, Cross J et al. The administration of rescue medication to children with prolonged acute convulsive seizures in a non-hospital setting: an exploratory survey of healthcare professionals’ perspective. Eur J Pediatr 2014; 173:773-779.
41. Munce S, Graham I, Salbach N et al. Perspectives of health care professionals on the facilitators and barriers to the implementation of a stroke rehabilitation guidelines cluster randomized controlled trial. BMC Health Serv Res 2017; 17(1): 440.
42. Alhassan R, Tsikata R, Tizaawaw R et al. Adherence to standard nursing protocols on nasogastric tube feeding in a secondary referral hospital in Ghana: comparing self-ratings by professional and auxiliary nurses. BMC Health Serv Res 2019; 19:119.
43. Huang J, Yang L, Zhuang Y, Qi H, Chen X, Lv K. Current status and influencing factors of barriers to enteral feeding of critically ill patients: A multicenter study. J Clin Nurs 2019; 28:677–685.
44. Burkitt K, Sinkowitz-Cochran R, Obrosky D et al. Survey of employee knowledge and attitudes before and after a multicenter Veterans' Administration quality improvement initiative to reduce nosocomial methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus infections. Am J Infect Control 2010; 38(4):274-82.
45. Cotta M, Robertson M, Tacey M, Marshall C, Thursky K, Liew D, & Buising, K et al. Attitudes towards antimicrobial stewardship: results from a large private hospital in Australia. Healthc. Infect 2014; 19(3):89-94.
46. Kiyoshi-Teo H, Cabana M, Froelicher E, Blegen M. Adherence to institution-specific ventilator-associated pneumonia prevention guidelines. Am J Crit Care 2014; 23(3):201-14.
47. Omran S, Barakat H, Kanaabi Muliira J, Aljadaa N. Knowledge, Experiences, and Barriers to Colorectal Cancer Screening: A Survey of Health Care Providers Working in Primary Care Settings. J Cancer Educ 2015; 30:53-61.
48. Presseau J, Mutsaers B, Al-Jaishi A, Squires J, McIntyre CW, Garg AX, et al. Barriers and facilitators to healthcare professional behaviour change in clinical trials using the Theoretical Domains Framework: a case study of a trial of individualized temperature-reduced haemodialysis. Trials 2017; 18:227.
49. Makhado L, Davhana-Maselesele M, Farley J. Barriers to tuberculosis and human immunodeficiency virus treatment guidelines adherence among nurses initiating and managing anti-retroviral therapy in KwaZulu-Natal and North West provinces. Curationis 2018; 41(1):e1-e8.
50. Currie K, King C, McAloney-Kocaman K et al. Barriers and enablers to meticillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus admission screening in hospitals: a mixed-methods study. J Hosp Infect 2019; 101(1):100-108.
51. Weller C, Richards C, Turnour L, Team V. Understanding factors influencing venous leg ulcer guideline implementation in Australian primary care. Int Wound J 2020; 17(3):804-818.
52. Jansson M, Ala-Kokkob T, Ylipalosaari P, Syrjälä H, Kyngäs H. Critical care nurses’ knowledge of, adherence to and barriers towards evidence-based guidelines for the prevention of ventilator-associated pneumonia — A survey study. Intensive Crit Care Nurs 2013; 29(4):216-27.
53. Aloush S. Does educating nurses with ventilator-associated pneumonia prevention guidelines improve their compliance? Am J Infect Control 2017; 45(9):969-973.
54. Storm-Versloot M, Knops A, Ubbink D, Goossens A, Legemate D, Vermeulen H. Long-term adherence to a local guideline on postoperative body temperature measurement: mixed methods analysis. J Eval Clin Pract 2012; 18(4):841-7.
55. Ersek M, Jablonski A. A mixed-methods approach to investigating the adoption of evidence-based pain practices in nursing homes. J Gerontol Nurs 2014; 40(7):52-60.
56. Katz D, Stewart K, Paez M et al. "Let Me Get You a Nicotine Patch": Nurses' Perceptions of Implementing Smoking Cessation Guidelines for Hospitalized Veterans. Mil Med 2016; 181(4):373-82.
57. Gustafsson I, Elmqvist C, From-Attebring M, Johansson I, Rask M. The Nurse Anesthetists’Adherence to Swedish National Recommendations to Maintain Normothermia in Patients During Surgery. J Perianesth Nurs 2017; 32(5):409-418.
58. Wolfensberger A, Meier M, Clack L, Schreiber P, Sax H. Preventing ventilator-associated pneumonia—a mixed-method study to find behavioral leverage for better protocol adherence. Infect Control Hosp Epidemiol 2018 Oct; 39(10):1222-1229.
59. De Meyer D, Van Hecke A, Verhaeghe S, Beeckman D. PROTECT – Trial: A cluster RCT to study the effectiveness of a repositioning aid and tailored repositioning to increase repositioning compliance. J Adv Nurs 2019;75(5):1085-1098.
60. Van den Berg M, Baysal Ö, Nelen W, Braat D, Beerendonk C, Hermens R. Professionals’ barriers in female oncofertility care and strategies for improvement. Hum Reprod 2019; 34(6):1074-82.
61. Dogherty E, Harrison M, Graham I, Vandyk A, Keeping-Burke L. Turning Knowledge Into Action at the Point-of-Care: The Collective Experience of Nurses Facilitating the Implementation of Evidence-Based Practice. Worldviews Evid Based Nurs 2013; 10(3):129-39.
62. Stenberg M, Wann-Hansson C. Health Care Professionals’ Attitudes and Compliance to Clinical Practice Guidelines to Prevent Falls and Fall Injuries. Worldviews Evid Based Nurs 2011; 8(2):87–95.
63. Cahill N, Murch L, Cook D, Heyland D. Implementing a multifaceted tailored intervention to improve nutrition adequacy in critically ill patients: results of a multicenter feasibility study. Crit Care 2014; 18(3):R96.
64. Spångfors M, Molt M, Samuelson K. National Early Warning Score: A survey of registered nurses' perceptions, experiences and barriers. J Clin Nurs 2020; 29(7-8):1187-1194.
65. Huis A, Holleman G, van Achterberg T, Grol R, Schoonhoven L, Hulscher M. Explaining the effects of two different strategies for promoting hand hygiene in hospital nurses: a process evaluation alongside a cluster randomised controlled trial. Implement Sci. 2013; 8:41.
66. Muller M, Carter E, Siddiqui N, Larson E. Hand Hygiene Compliance in an Emergency Department: The Effect of Crowding. Acad Emerg Med 2015; 22(10):1218-21.
67. Knops A, Storm-Versloot M, Mank A. et al. Factors influencing long-term adherence to two previously implemented hospital guidelines. Int J Qual Health Care 2010; 22(5): 421-9.
68. Macmillan D and Chavis D. Sense of community: A definition and theory. J. Community Psychol 1986; 14(1):6-23.
69. Harillo-Acevedo D, Ramos-Morcillo A, Ruzafa-Martinez M. Factors associated with breastfeeding support from health care professionals by implementing a Clinical Practice Guideline. Birth 2019; 46:146-56.
70. McIntosh B, Khatchadourian K and Amed S. British Columbian Healthcare Providers' Perspectives on Facilitators and Barriers to Adhering to Pediatric Diabetes Treatment Guidelines. Can J Diabetes 2017; 41(2):224-240.
71. Aloush S, Alsaraireh F. Nurses’ compliance with central line associated blood stream infection prevention guidelines. Saudi Med J 2018; 39(3):273-279.
72. Chavali S, Menon V, Shukla U. Hand hygiene compliance among healthcare workers in an accredited tertiary care hospital. Indian J Crit Care Med 2014; 18(10):689-693.
73. Snelgrove-Clarke E, Davies B, Flowerdew G, Young D. Implementing a Fetal Health Surveillance Guideline in Clinical Practice: A Pragmatic Randomized Controlled Trial of Action Learning. Worldviews Evid Based Nurs 2015; 12(5):281-288.
74. Tinkle M, Tigges B, Boursaw B, McFarlane D. Adherence to the Women’s Preventive Services Guidelines in the Affordable Care Act. J Obstet Gynecol Neonatal Nurs 2016; 45(6):813–824.
75. Efstathiou G, Papastavrou E, Raftopoulos V, Merkouris A. Factors influencing nurses’ compliance with Standard Precautions in order to avoid occupational exposure to microorganisms: A focus group study. BMC Nurs 2011; 10:1.
76. Holmen I, Seneza C, Nyiranzayisaba B, Nyiringabo V, Bienfait M, Safdar N. Improving Hand Hygiene Practices in a Rural Hospital in Sub-Saharan Africa. Infect Control Hosp Epidemiol 2016; 37(7):834-9.
77. Yanke E, Moriarty H, Carayon P, Safdar N. A qualitative, interprofessional analysis of barriers to and facilitators of implementation of the Department of Veterans Affairs' Clostridium difficile prevention bundle using a human factors engineering approach. Am J Infect Control 2018; 46(3), 276-284.
78. Förberg U, Unbeck M, Wallin L. et al. Effects of computer reminders on complications of peripheral venous catheters and nurses’ adherence to a guideline in paediatric care—a cluster randomised study. Implement Sci 2016; 11:10.
79. Friese C, Yang J, Mendelsohn-Victor K and McCullagh M. Randomized Controlled Trial of an Intervention to Improve Nurses' Hazardous Drug Handling. Oncol Nurs Forum 2019; 46(2):248-256.
80. Stahmeyer J, Lutze B, von Lengerke T, Chaberny I, Krauth C. Hand hygiene in intensive care units: a matter of time? J Hosp Infect 2017; 95(4):338-343.
81. Heidke P, Madsen W, Langham E. Registered nurses as role models for healthy lifestyles. Aust J Adv Nurs 2020; 37(2).
82. Garcia C, Lothamer H, McKim Mitchell E. Provider-Identified Barriers to Cervical Cancer Screening and Perceptions Toward Self-Collection of Human Papillomavirus in Southwest Virginia. Public Health Nurs 2016; 33(6):539–546.
83. Baker R, Camosso-Stefinovic J, Gillies C. et al. Tailored interventions to overcome identified barriers to change: effects on professional practice and health care outcomes. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2010, 3, CD005470.
84. May C, Sibley A, Hunt K. The nursing work of hospital-based clinical practice guideline implementation: an explanatory systematic review using Normalisation Process Theory. Int J Nurs Stud 2014; 51(2):289-99.
85. Bouchoucha S, Kilpatrick M, Lucas J, Phillips N, Hutchinson A. The Factors Influencing Adherence to Standard Precautions Scale - Student version (FIASP- SV): A psychometric validation. Infect Dis Health 2021; 26(2):85-94.