Main Article Content
care pathways, clinical pathways, meta-analysis, multi-interventions, outcomes, systematic review
Clinical pathways represent a multi-disciplinary approach to translate clinical practice guidelines into practical interventions. The literature from 2010 onward regarding the efficacy of adopting a clinical pathway on patient-related outcomes within the in-hospital setting has been not synthesized yet. For this reason, this systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials aimed to critically synthesize the literature from 2010 onward about the efficacy of clinical pathways, compared with standard of care, on patient-related outcomes in different populations, and to determine the effects of clinical pathways on patient outcomes. We searched PubMed, Scopus, CINAHL, and reference lists of the included studies. Two independent reviewers screened the 360 identified articles and selected fifteen eligible articles, which were evaluated for content and risk of bias. Eleven studies were finally included. Given the commonalities of the measured outcomes, a meta-analysis including eight studies was performed to evaluate the effect size of the associations between clinical pathways and quality of life (OR=1.472 [0.483–4.486]; p=0.496), and two meta-analyses, including four studies, were performed to evaluate the effect sizes of the associations between clinical pathways with satisfaction (OR=2.226 [0.868–5.708]; p=0.096) and length of stay (OR=0,585 [0.349–0.982]; p=0.042). Reduced length of stay appeared to be associated with clinical pathways, while it remains unclear whether adopting clinical pathways could improve levels of quality of life and satisfaction. More primary research is required to determine in specific populations the efficacy of clinical pathways on patient-related outcomes.
2. Djulbegovic B, Elqayam S. Many faces of rationality: Implications of the great rationality debate for clinical decision-making. J Eval Clin Pract. 2017 Oct 1;23(5):915–22.
3. Rotter T, Kinsman L, James EL, Machotta A, Gothe H, Willis J, et al. Clinical pathways: effects on professional practice, patient outcomes, length of stay and hospital costs. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2010;17(3):CD006632.
4. Vanhaecht K, Panella M, van Zelm R, Sermeus W. An overview on the history and concept of care pathways as complex interventions. Int J Care Pathways. 2010 Sep 1;14(3):117–23.
5. Bower KA. Clinical pathways: 12 lessons learned over 25 years of experience. Int J Care Pathways. 2009 Nov 1;13(2):78–81.
6. Djulbegovic B, Hozo I, Dale W. Transforming clinical practice guidelines and clinical pathways into fast-and-frugal decision trees to improve clinical care strategies. J Eval Clin Pract. 2018 Oct 1;24(5):1247–54.
7. Kinsman L, Rotter T, James E, Snow P, Willis J. What is a clinical pathway? Development of a definition to inform the debate. BMC Med. 2010 May 27;8(1):31.
8. Dykes PC, Currie LM, Cimino JJ. Adequacy of evolving national standardized terminologies for interdisciplinary coded concepts in an automated clinical pathway. J Biomed Inform. 2003 Aug 1;36(4–5):313–25.
9. Panella M. The impact of pathways: a significant decrease in mortality. Int J Care Pathways. 2009 Nov 1;13(2):57–61.
10. Kwan J, Sandercock PA. In-hospital care pathways for stroke. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2004 Oct 18;2004(4):CD002924.
11. Vanhaecht K, Ovretveit J, Elliott MJ, Sermeus W, Ellershaw J, Panella M. Have we drawn the wrong conclusions about the value of care pathways? Is a Cochrane review appropriate? Eval Health Prof. 2012 Mar 27;35(1):28–42.
12. Lawal AK, Rotter T, Kinsman L, Machotta A, Ronellenfitsch U, Scott SD, et al. What is a clinical pathway? Refinement of an operational definition to identify clinical pathway studies for a Cochrane systematic review. BMC Med. 2016 Feb 23;14(1):35.
13. Štrbac S, Rakić S, Vujić-Aleksić V, Škrbić R. The role of clinical pathways on healthcare quality improvement in hospitals for patient undergoing total hip replacement. Scr Med (Brno). 2020;51(2):87–92.
14. Caruso R, Micallo G, Cessa M, di Bari MTC, De Marzo D, Diamanti O, et al. Italian Association of Cancer Nurses (AIIAO) is moving forward within a complex and fast-changing scenario: Our current agenda takes shape. J Cancer Policy. 2018 Mar 1;15:15–7.
15. Liberati A, Altman DG, Tetzlaff J, Mulrow C, Gøtzsche PC, Ioannidis JPA, et al. The PRISMA statement for reporting systematic reviews and meta-analyses of studies that evaluate healthcare interventions: explanation and elaboration. BMJ. 2009;339:b2700.
16. Stovold E, Beecher D, Foxlee R, Noel-Storr A. Study flow diagrams in Cochrane systematic review updates: An adapted PRISMA flow diagram. Systematic Reviews.2014. Available from: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24886533/
17. Huang X, Lin J, Demner-Fushman D. Evaluation of PICO as a knowledge representation for clinical questions. AMIA Annu Symp Proc. 2006;2006:359–63.
18. Cochrane. Suggested risk of bias criteria for EPOC reviews. 2017 [cited 2020 Sep 2]. Available from: https://epoc.cochrane.org/sites/epoc.cochrane.org/files/public/uploads/Resources-for-authors2017/suggested_risk_of_bias_criteria_for_epoc_reviews.pdf
19. Higgins JPT, Thompson SG, Spiegelhalter DJ. A re-evaluation of random-effects meta-analysis. J R Stat Soc Ser A (Statistics Soc [Internet]. 2009 Jan 1 [cited 2020 Sep 2];172(1):137–59. Available from: http://doi.wiley.com/10.1111/j.1467-985X.2008.00552.x
20. Higgins JPT, Thompson SG. Quantifying heterogeneity in a meta-analysis. Stat Med. 2002 Jun 15;21(11):1539–58.
21. Chaimani A, Higgins JPT, Mavridis D, Spyridonos P, Salanti G. Graphical Tools for Network Meta-Analysis in STATA. Haibe-Kains B, editor. PLoS One. 2013 Oct 3;8(10):e76654.
22. De Luca R, Bramanti A, De Cola MC, Trifiletti A, Tomasello P, Torrisi M, et al. Tele-health-care in the elderly living in nursing home: the first Sicilian multimodal approach. Aging Clin Exp Res. 2016 Aug 1;28(4):753–9.
23. Linden A, Butterworth S. A comprehensive hospital-based intervention to reduce readmissions for chronically ill patients: a randomized controlled trial - PubMed. Am J Manag Care. 2014;20(10):783–92.
24. Dykes PC, Carroll DL, Hurley A, Lipsitz S, Benoit A, Chang F, et al. Fall prevention in acute care hospitals: A randomized trial. JAMA - J Am Med Assoc. 2010;304(17):1912–8.
25. Kruis AL, Boland MRS, Assendelft WJJ, Gussekloo J, Tsiachristas A, Stijnen T, et al. effectiveness of integrated disease management for primary care chronic obstructive pulmonary disease patients: Results of cluster randomised trial. BMJ. 2014 Sep 10;349.
26. Krebber AMH, Jansen F, Witte BI, Cuijpers P, de Bree R, Becker-Commissaris A, et al. Stepped care targeting psychological distress in head and neck cancer and lung cancer patients: A randomized, controlled trial. Ann Oncol. 2016;27(9):1754–60.
27. Ko FWS, Cheung NK, Rainer TH, Lum C, Wong I, Hui DSC. Comprehensive care programme for patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease: A randomised controlled trial. Thorax. 2017;72(2):122–8.
28. Kirshbaum MN, Dent J, Stephenson J, Topping AE, Allinson V, McCoy M, et al. Open access follow-up care for early breast cancer: a randomised controlled quality of life analysis. Eur J Cancer Care (Engl). 2017;26(4).
29. Johnson-Warrington V, Rees K, Gelder C, Morgan MD, Singh SJ. Can a supported self-management program for COPD upon hospital discharge reduce readmissions? A randomized controlled trial. Int J COPD. 2016;11(1):1161–9.
30. Hussain ZI, Lim M, Stojkovic S. Role of clinical pathway in improving the quality of care for patients with faecal incontinence: A randomised trial. World J Gastrointest Pharmacol Ther. 2017;8(1):89.
31. Field M, Wenke R, Sabet A, Lawrie M, Cardell E. Implementing Cough Reflex Testing in a Clinical Pathway for Acute Stroke: A Pragmatic Randomised Controlled Trial. Dysphagia. 2018;33(6):827–39.
32. Fan VS, Michael Gaziano J, Lew R, Bourbeau J, Adams SG, Leatherman S, et al. A comprehensive care management program to prevent chronic obstructive pulmonary disease hospitalizations: A randomized, controlled trial. Ann Intern Med. 2012;156(10):673–83.
33. Gregersen TL, Green A, Frausing E, Ringbæk T, Brøndum E, Ulrik CS. Do telemedical interventions improve quality of life in patients with COPD? A systematic review. Int J COPD [Internet]. 2016;11(1):809–22.
34. Engström CP, Persson LO, Larsson S, Sullivan M. Health-related quality of life in COPD: why both disease-specific and generic measures should be used | European Respiratory Society. Eur Respir J. 2001;18(1):69–76.
35. Caruso R, Belloni S, Dellafiore F, Biagioli V, Piredda A, Arrigoni C. A bottom-up approach to prioritize the scientific activities of Italian Association of Cancer Nurses (AIIAO): Questionnaire validation and pilot study. Recenti Prog Med. 2019;110(10):480–9.
36. Biagioli V, Belloni S, Albanesi B, Piredda A, Caruso R. Comment on “The experience on coronavirus disease 2019 and cancer from an oncology hub institution in Milan, Lombardy Region” and reflections from the Italian Association of Oncology Nurses. Vol. 135, European Journal of Cancer. Elsevier Ltd; 2020. p. 8–10. Available from: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32521294/
37. Caruso R, Di Pasquale C, Lichosik D, Dellafiore F, Pittella F. Report on the 2013 European Multidisciplinary Cancer Congress - ECC 17, Amsterdam, 27 September-1 October 2013: Nursing highlights. Ecancermedicalscience; 2013. Available from: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24171051/
38. Caruso R, Belloni S, Albanesi B, Piredda A, Biagioli V. Comment on “pathways to psychological wellbeing for patients with bladder cancer and their partners-in-care” and contextualization in the COVID-19 pandemic. Eur J Oncol Nurs. 2020 Aug 5;
39. Ng JHY, Luk BHK. Patient satisfaction: Concept analysis in the healthcare context. Patient Educ Couns. 2019 Apr 1;102(4):790–6.
40. Toy JM, Drechsler A, Waters RC. Clinical pathways for primary care: Current use, interest and perceived usability. J Am Med Informatics Assoc. 2018;25(7):901–6.