The Legal Status of General Practitioners at the dawn of the New Primary Care in Italy
Keywords:
Primary care, general practitioner, employment status, health reform, comparative health law, public health lawAbstract
A debate is developing in Italy on the reform of the employment status of general practitioners. The dispute was prompted by the extraordinary resources the European Union has allocated to Italy on the condition of several structural reforms, among which lies the renewal of the primary care system. One of the most debated questions is whether general practitioners should become civil servants or remain autonomous workers. The issue is not only relevant to the quality and efficiency of primary care but is propitious for improving the legal certainty of this “hybrid figure” in Italian health law. The commentary suggests that, from a public law point of view, the employment status of civil servants better agrees with the foreseeable conditions of general practitioners working in Community Houses. In any case, national and regional policymakers must take into consideration possible controversies and litigation arising from an inappropriate qualification of the legal status of general practitioners in building the new system of Italian primary care.
References
1. Filippini T, Vinceti SR. Italian National Recovery and Resilience Plan: a Healthcare Renaissance after the COVID-19 crisis? Recovery and Resilience beyond COVID-19. Acta Biomed. 2021; 92(S6): e2021463.
2. Governo italiano. Piano Nazionale di Ripresa e Resilienza [Internet]. www.governo.it. 2021 [cited 2021 Sep 19]. Available on: https:// www.governo.it/it/articolo/piano-nazionale-diripresa-e-resilienza/16782.
3. Per una medicina generale veramente al passo coi tempi - Quotidiano Sanità [Internet].
[cited 2021 Oct 29]. Available on: https://www. quotidianosanita.it/studi-e-analisi/articolo. php?articolo_id=98060.
4. Sulla medicina generale più slogan che conoscenza. Una lettera dal Portogallo da un medico italiano - Quotidiano Sanità [Internet].
[cited 2021 Oct 29]. Available on: https://www. quotidianosanita.it/lettere-al-direttore/articolo. php?articolo_id=99203.
5. La medicina generale in Italia, dal medico di fiducia dei cittadini ai medici subordinati ai palazzi? - Quotidiano Sanità [Internet]. [cited 2021 Oct 29]. Available on: http://www.quotidianosanita.it/lettere-al-direttore/articolo. php?articolo_id=99066.
6. Speranza alla Fimmg: “Dipendenza medici di famiglia non è il cuore della vicenda. Ora al lavoro per integrazione mmg con resto del Ssn.” E annuncia: “Più risorse per il Fondo sanitario” - Quotidiano Sanità [Internet]. http:// www.quotidianosanita.it/. 2021 [cited 2021 Oct 28]. Available on: http://www.quotidianosanita. it/governo-e-parlamento/articolo.php?articolo_ id=98795.
7. Lettera aperta a Speranza: “La dipendenza per i medici di famiglia è il cuore della vicenda”- Quotidiano Sanità [Internet]. http://www.quotidianosanita.it/. 2021 [cited 2021 Oct 28]. Available on: http://www.quotidianosanita.it/lavoroe-professioni/articolo.php?articolo_id=98978.
8. Non vogliamo diventare impiegati, no alla dipendenza dei medici di famiglia - Quotidiano Sanità [Internet]. http://www.quotidianosanita.it/. 2021 [cited 2021 Oct 28]. Available on: http://www. quotidianosanita.it/lettere-al-direttore/articolo. php?articolo_id=99170.
9. Costantino C, Mazzucco W, Restivo V, et al. Proposal for an Alliance Between Healthcare
and Legal Area Professionals for Shared Public Health and Preventive Strategies in Italy and Europe. Front Public Health. 2020 Jul 23; 8: 324. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2020.00324.
10. Vinceti SR. (in press) COVID-19 Compulsory Vaccination of Healthcare Workers and the Italian Constitution. Ann Ig. 2021 Oct 11. doi:
10.7416/ai.2021.2468. Epub ahead of print.
11. Normattiva [Internet]. [cited 2021 Oct 27]. Available on: https://www.normattiva.it/
12. SISAC - Struttura Interregionale Sanitari Convenzionati [Internet]. [cited 2021 Oct 27]. Available on: https://www.sisac.info/anteprimaNewsHome. do?tipo=WEB&idArea=201011221610481056& idNews=20200623101814808.
13. Giuffrè - DeJure [Internet]. [cited 2021 Oct 27]. Available on: https://dejure.it/#/home.
14. OECD. Realising the Potential of Primary Health
Care [Internet]. OECD; 2020 [cited 2021 Sep 18]. (OECD Health Policy Studies). Available on: https://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/social-issuesmigration-health/realising-the-potential-ofprimary-health-care_a92adee4-en.
15. OECD. Health at a Glance: Europe 2020. State of Health in the EU Cycle. OECD, 2020. 236 p.
16. Ministero della Salute. Rapporto annuale sull’attività di ricovero ospedaliero: Dati SDO 2019 [Internet]. 2020 [cited 2021 Oct 28]. Available on: https://www.salute.gov.it/portale/documentazione/p6_2_2_1.jsp?lingua=italiano&id=3002.
17. Ferrè F, Belvis A, Valerio L, et al. Italy: Health System Review. Health Syst Transit. 2014; 164: 1-168.
18. OECD. OECD Reviews of Health Care Quality: Italy 2014 Raising Standards: Raising Standards. OECD Publishing, 2015. 197 p.
19. Armeni P, Compagni A, Longo F. Multiprofessional Primary Care Units: What Affects the Clinical Performance of Italian General Practitioners? Med Care Res Rev. 2014 Aug; 71(4): 315-36. doi: 10.1177/1077558714536618.
20. Odone A, Saccani E, Chiesa V, et al. The implementation of a Community Health Centre-based primary care model in Italy. The experience of the Case della Salute in the Emilia-Romagna Region. Ann Ist Super Sanita. 2016; 52(1): 70-7. doi: 10.4415/ANN_16_01_13.
21. Shaw SE, Meads G. Extending primary care: potential learning from Italy. Prim Health Care Res Dev. 2012 Oct; 13(4): 289-93. doi: 10.1017/ S1463423612000011.
22. Barsanti S, Bonciani M. General practitioners:
Between integration and co-location. The case of primary care centers in Tuscany, Italy. Health Serv Manage Res. 2019 Feb; 32(1): 2-15. doi: 10.1177/0951484818757154. Epub 2018 Mar 7.
23. Ministero della Salute. Annuario statistico del servizio sanitario nazionale - anno 2019 [Internet]. 2021 [cited 2021 Oct 28]. Available on: https://www.salute.gov.it/portale/news/ p3_2_1_1_1.jsp?lingua=italiano&menu=notizie &p=dalministero&id=5523.
24. Rapporto Oasi 2020. Osservatorio sulle aziende e sul sistema sanitario italiano. EGEA, 2020. 723 p.
25. Rapporto Oasi 2019. Osservatorio sulle aziende e sul sistema sanitario italiano. EGEA, 2019. 696 p.
26. Amelung V, Stein V, Goodwin N, Balicer R, Nolte E, Suter E. Handbook Integrated Care. Springer, 2017. 578 p.
27. Kurotschka PK, Serafini A, Demontis M, et al. General Practitioners’ Experiences During the First Phase of the COVID-19 Pandemic in Italy: A Critical Incident Technique Study. Front Public Health. 2021 Feb; 9: 623904. doi: 10.3389/ fpubh.2021.623904.
28. Marcadelli S, Stievano A, Rocco G. Policy proposals for a new welfare: the development of the family and community nurse in Italy as the key to promote social capital and social innovation. Prim Health Care Res Dev. 2019 Jun 28; 20:
e109. doi: 10.1017/S146342361800083X.
29. Supreme Court of Cassation, criminal, IV sec., judgment no. 44326. 2003.
30. Supreme Court of Cassation, civil, III sec., judgment no. 6243. 2015.
31. Accordo Collettivo Nazionale per la disciplina dei rapporti con i medici di medicina generale. Mar 23, 2005.
32. Accordo Collettivo Nazionale per la disciplina dei rapporti con i medici di medicina generale. Jul 29, 2009.
33. Accordo Collettivo Nazionale per la disciplina dei rapporti con i medici di medicina generale. Jul 8, 2010.
34. Accordo Collettivo Nazionale per la disciplina dei rapporti con i medici di medicina generale. Jun 21, 2018.
35. Accordo Collettivo Nazionale per la disciplina dei rapporti con i medici di medicina generale. Jun 18, 2020.
36. Accordo Collettivo Nazionale per la disciplina dei rapporti con i medici di medicina generale.
Oct 30, 2020.
37. Supreme Court of Cassation, united sections, judgment no. 20344. 2005.
38. Medea G. Piani Terapeutici e malattie croniche territoriali: una storia infinita. Riv Soc Ital Med Gen. 2019; 26(1): 7-9.
39. “Dipendenza per i medici di famiglia? Se passa lascio la professione. Per far funzionare le Case della Comunità servono i Micro team di mmg.” Intervista al segretario Fimmg Silvestro Scotti - Quotidiano Sanità [Internet]. http://www.quotidianosanita.it/. 2021 [cited 2021 Oct 28]. Available on: http://www.quotidianosanita.it/lavoroe-professioni/articolo.php?articolo_id=98771.
40. Digennaro P. Subordination or subjection? A study about the dividing line between subordinate work and self-employment in six European legal systems. Labour and Law Issues. 2020; 6(1): 1-47. doi: 10.6092/issn.2421-2695/11254.
41. Italian Constitutional Court, judgment no. 111. 1981.
42. Italian Constitutional Court, judgment no. 3. 1957.
43. Italian Constitutional Court, judgment no. 15. 1960.
44. Barsotti V, Carozza PG, Cartabia M, Simoncini A. Italian Constitutional Justice in Global Context. Oxford University Press, 2016. 329 p.
45. Perlingieri G. Reasonableness and Balancing in Recent Interpretation by the Italian Constitutional Court. Italian Law J 2018; 4(2): 385-420.
46. Morrone A. Constitutional Adjudication and the
Principle of Reasonableness. In: Bongiovanni G, Sartor G, Valentini C, eds. Reasonableness and Law [Internet]. Dordrecht: Springer Netherlands; 2009 [cited 2021 Oct 28]. p. 215–42. (Law and Philosophy Library). Available on: https:// doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4020-8500-0_10.
47. Cegolon L, Heymann WC, Lange JH, Xodo C. Improving Italian general practice training: the role of academia. BJGP Open. 2017 Jun 14; 1(2): bjgpopen17X100989. doi: 10.3399/ bjgpopen17X100989.
48. Garattini L, Padula A. Urgent reforms for general practice in Italy. Eur J Intern Med. 2019 Jun; 64: e17. doi: 10.1016/j.ejim.2019.04.004. Epub 2019 Apr 20.
49. Colombo A, Parisi G. Seeking identity in primary care. A survey on GPs trainees in Lombardy. Eur J Intern Med. 2019 Jun; 64: e14-6. doi: 10.1016/j.ejim.2019.03.015. Epub 2019 Apr 3.
50. Badinella Martini M, D’Ascenzo F, Zaninelli A, Garattini L, Mannucci PM. The dark age of Italian general practice research – An Italian matter. Eur J Intern Med. 2020 Mar; 73: 98.9. doi: 10.1016/j.ejim.2019.12.002. Epub 2019 Dec 13.
51. Repubblicana italiana. Decreto Legislativo [Internet]. 368 Aug 17, 1999. Available on: https://www. normattiva.it/uri-res/N2Ls?urn:nir:stato:decreto.l egislativo:1999;368~art40!vig=#:~:text=1.,e%20 istituzioni%20pubbliche%20e%20private.
52. Repubblica italiana. Decreto Legislativo [Internet]. 277 Jul 8, 2003. Available on: https://www. normattiva.it/uri-res/N2Ls?urn:nir:stato:decreto. legislativo:1999;368~art40!vig=#:~:text=1., e%20istituzioni%20pubbliche%20e%20private.
53. Ministero della Salute. Decreto [Internet]. Mar 7, 2006. Available on: https://www.gazzettaufficiale.it/eli/id/2006/03/13/06A02595/sg.
54. Gabanelli M, Gerevini M, Ravizza S. Medici di base, inchiesta sulla loro lobby di potere | Milena Gabanelli [Internet]. Corriere della Sera.
2021 [cited 2021 Oct 27]. Available on: https:// www.corriere.it/dataroom-milena-gabanelli/ medici-base-famiglia-inchiesta-lobby-poteresindacati-sanita-salute-corsi-formazione-fimmgsimg-snami-conflitto-interesse-corporazionedottori-prestazioni-pazienti/866e4bda-195611ec-af75-f327f3924e85-va.shtml.
55. Gabanelli M, Gerevini M, Ravizza S. La lobby che governa i medici di famiglia | La diretta di Milena Gabanelli [Internet]. Video: ultime notizie - Corriere TV. 2021 [cited 2021 Oct 27]. Available on: https://video.corriere.it/lobby-chegoverna-medici-famiglia/8c83465a-1ab5-11ec8604-8b77798ec285.
56. Maxeiner JR. Some Realism about Legal Certainty in the Globalization of the Rule of Law. Houst J Int Law. 2008; 31(1): 27-46.
57. OECD. Government at a Glance 2021 [Internet]. Paris: OECD; 2021 Jul [cited 2021 Oct 26]. Available on: https://www.oecd-ilibrary. org/governance/government-at-a-glance-2021 _73c2f7e9-en.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0) which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Transfer of Copyright and Permission to Reproduce Parts of Published Papers.
Authors retain the copyright for their published work. No formal permission will be required to reproduce parts (tables or illustrations) of published papers, provided the source is quoted appropriately and reproduction has no commercial intent. Reproductions with commercial intent will require written permission and payment of royalties.