La fluorazione delle acque tra sanità pubblica e diritto pubblico: una valutazione comparata della normativa di alcuni Paesi e delle relative implicazioni di medicina preventiva
Keywords:
Public health; drinking water; fluoride; law; regulations; policyAbstract
Background. Among health professionals and health policymakers concern is growing as to the difficulty of balancing the prevention of dental caries through cost-effective interventions and the need to limit unnecessary exposure of the population, and especially children, to environmental chemicals. In this respect, the use of water fluoridation to prevent tooth decay epitomizes the dilemma by raising questions relevant to both public health and public law, ranging from the balance of public health and medical selfdetermination, the division of powers between local or national authorities over water fluoridation, and the need to avoid the adverse effects of socioeconomic inequalities as well as both under- and over-exposure.
Study design. We carried out a narrative review by searching the relevant literature about the laws and rules related to drinking water fluoridation at the community level in the US, UK, and Europe, in order to discuss how the issue is handled from both a public health and public law perspective.
Methods. Sources of data for this review were the biomedical and legal literature retrieved by searching online databases, and websites of public health and legal institutions.
Results and Conclusions. We found that water fluoridation is still largely adopted throughout the US, while in the UK and particularly in the European Union only a minor part of the population is subject to it. In addition, the recommended and maximum allowed amounts of fluoride in drinking water are being adapted to the public health recommendations and the new regulations, within an evolving evaluation of the epidemiologic evidence and the risk assessment currently in progress by two major regulatory agencies, the US National Toxicology Program - NTP and the European Food Safety Authority - EFSA. Under a comparative public law perspective, the three investigated legislations are facing a reassessment of their policies and regulations, to allow for effective and safe public health measures in the field of water fluoridation and more generally for a preferred use of topical fluoride for caries prevention. A consistent trend across these legislations is the choice to centralize at the national level regulatory and management issues related to water fluoridation, and to carefully balance benefits for dental caries prevention in children and the potential risks of systemic overexposure associated with excess fluoride intake, by promptly responding to the evolving indications by the scientific community and the public health professionals.
References
1. Bellante De Martiis G, Borgioli A, Gavasci R, Simonetti D’Arca A. [The feasibility of fluoridation of the drinking water in the Rome metropolitan area]. Ann Ig. 1994; 6(4-6): 867-879.
2. Parnell C, Whelton H, O’Mullane D. Water fluoridation. Eur
Arch Paediatr Dent. 2009; 10(3): 141-148. doi: 10.1007/ BF03262675.
3. Fabiani L, Mosca G, Giannini D, Tarsitani G. [The epidemiology of dental caries in childhood: the most recent studies in Italy]. Ann Ig. 1998; 10(4): 223-233.
4. Petti S, Iannazzo S, Gemelli G, Rocchi R, Novello MR, Ortensi V, et al. [Incidence of caries in a sample of 3-7-year old children in Rome who were not included in population prevention programs]. Ann Ig. 2001; 13(4): 329-338.
5. Billa AL, Sukhabogi JR, Doshi D, Jummala S, Turaga SS. Correlation of self-esteem with oral hygiene behaviour and oral health status among adult dental patients. Ann Ig. 2023; 35(5): 534-545. doi: 10.7416/ai.2023.2565.
6. McDonagh MS, Whiting PF, Wilson PM, Sutton AJ, Chestnutt I, Cooper J, et al. Systematic review of water fluoridation. BMJ. 2000; 321(7265): 855-859. doi: 10.1136/ bmj.321.7265.855.
7. Iheozor-Ejiofor Z, Worthington HV, Walsh T, O’Malley L, Clarkson JE, Macey R, et al. Water fluoridation for the prevention of dental caries. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2015; 2015(6): CD010856. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD010856. pub2.
8. Senevirathna L, Ratnayake HE, Jayasinghe N, Gao J, Zhou X, Nanayakkara S. Water fluoridation in Australia: a systematic review. Environ Res. 2023; 237(Pt 1): 116915. doi: 10.1016/j.envres.2023.116915.
9. Wurzburg J, Parver CP. Community water fluoridation around the Nation: significant case law and legislation. Health Law Policy Brief. 2013; 7(1): 1-20.
10. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). Community water fluoridation; 2023. Available from: https:// www.cdc.gov/fluoridation/index.html. [Last accessed: 2023 December 30].
11. Till C, Green R. Controversy: the evolving science of fluoride: when new evidence doesn’t conform with existing beliefs. Pediatr Res. 2021; 90(5): 1093-1095. doi: 10.1038/ s41390-020-0973-8.
12. Tobias G, Mordechai F, Tali C, Yaron B, Beatrice GP, Jonathan M, et al. The effect of community water fluoridation cessation on children’s dental health: a national experience. Isr J Health Policy Res. 2022; 11(1): 4. doi: 10.1186/s13584022-00514-z.
13. Krishnankutty N, Storgaard Jensen T, Kjaer J, Jorgensen JS, Nielsen F, Grandjean P. Public-health risks from tea drinking: fluoride exposure. Scand J Public Health. 2022; 50(3): 355-361. doi: 10.1177/1403494821990284.
14. Goodman C, Hall M, Green R, Hornung R, Martinez-Mier EA, Lanphear B, et al. Maternal fluoride exposure, fertility and birth outcomes: the MIREC cohort. Environ Adv. 2022; 7: 100135. doi: 10.1016/j.envadv.2021.100135.
15. Aoun A, Darwiche F, Al Hayek S, Doumit J. The fluoride debate: the Pros and Cons of fluoridation. Prev Nutr Food Sci. 2018; 23(3): 171-180. doi: 10.3746/ pnf.2018.23.3.171.
16. American Academy of Pediatric Dentistry (AAPD). Fluoride therapy. The Reference Manual of Pediatric Dentistry. Chicago, IL: American Academy of Pediatric Dentistry; 2023.
17. Toumba KJ, Twetman S, Splieth C, Parnell C, van Loveren C, Lygidakis N. Guidelines on the use of fluoride for caries prevention in children: an updated EAPD policy document. Eur Arch Paediatr Dent. 2019; 20(6): 507-516. doi: 10.1007/ s40368-019-00464-2.
18. European Food Safety Authority (EFSA). Scientific opinion on fluoride in food and drinking water. Art. 29 Scientific Opinion EFSA-Q-2021-00358; 2021. Available from: https://open.efsa.europa.eu/questions/EFSA-Q-2021-00358. [Last accessed: 2023 December 30].
19. Casaglia A, Cassini MA, Condo R, Iaculli F, Cerroni L. Dietary fluoride intake by children: when to use a fluoride toothpaste? Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2021; 18(11): 5791. doi: 10.3390/ijerph18115791.
20. Jurgensen N, Petersen PE. Promoting oral health of children through schools--results from a WHO global survey 2012. Community Dent Health. 2013; 30(4): 204-218.
21. Yeung CA, Chong LY, Glenny AM. Fluoridated milk for preventing dental caries. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2015; 2015(9): CD003876. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD003876. pub4.
22. Veneri F, Vinceti SR, Filippini T. Fluoride and caries prevention: a scoping review of public health policies. Ann Ig. 2024 Jan 17. doi: 10.7416/ai.2024.2593. Epub ahead of print.
23. Conti G, Veneri F, Amadori F, Garzoni A, Majorana A, Bardellini E. Evaluation of antibacterial activity of a bioactive restorative material versus a Glass-Ionomer cement on Streptococcus mutans: in-vitro study. Dent J (Basel). 2023; 11(6): 149. doi: 10.3390/dj11060149.
24. Weyant RJ, Tracy SL, Anselmo TT, Beltran-Aguilar ED, Donly KJ, Frese WA, et al. Topical fluoride for caries prevention: executive summary of the updated clinical recommendations and supporting systematic review. J Am Dent Assoc. 2013; 144(11): 1279-1291. doi: 10.14219/jada. archive.2013.0057.
25. Veneri F, Bardellini E, Amadori F, Gobbi E, Belotti R, Majorana A. Antibacterial activity of new hydrophilic sealants: In vitro study. J Indian Soc Pedod Prev Dent. 2020; 38(4): 387-392. doi: 10.4103/JISPPD.JISPPD_442_20.
26. National Toxicology Program, US Department of Health and Human Services. Fluoride: assessment for developmental neurotoxicity; 2023. Available from: https:// ntp.niehs.nih.gov/whatwestudy/assessments/noncancer/ ongoing/fluoride. [Last accessed: 2023 December 30].
27. Veneri F, Vinceti M, Generali L, Giannone ME, Mazzoleni E, Birnbaum LS, et al. Fluoride exposure and cognitive neurodevelopment: systematic review and dose-response meta-analysis. Environ Res. 2023; 221: 115239. doi: 10.1016/j.envres.2023.115239.
28. Veneri F, Iamandii I, Vinceti M, Birnbaum LS, Generali L, Consolo U, et al. Fluoride exposure and skeletal fluorosis: a systematic review and dose-response meta-analysis. Curr Environ Health Rep. 2023. doi: 10.1007/s40572-023 -00412-9.
29. Fiore G, Veneri F, Di Lorenzo RD, Generali L, Vinceti M, Filippini T. Fluoride exposure and ADHD: a systematic review of epidemiological studies. Medicina. 2023; 59(4): 797. doi: 10.3390/medicina59040797.
30. Iamandii I, De Pasquale L, Giannone ME, Veneri F, Generali L, Consolo U, et al. Does fluoride exposure affect thyroid function? A systematic review and dose-response meta-analysis. Environ Res. 2024; 242: 117759. doi: 10.1016/j.envres.2023.117759.
31. Grandjean P, Meddis A, Nielsen F, Beck IH, Bilenberg N, Goodman CV, et al. Dose dependence of prenatal fluoride exposure associations with cognitive performance at school age in three prospective studies. Eur J Public Health. 2023: ckad170. doi: 10.1093/eurpub/ckad170.
32. Hall M, Lanphear B, Chevrier J, Hornung R, Green R, Goodman C, et al. Fluoride exposure and hypothyroidism in a Canadian pregnancy cohort. Sci Total Environ. 2023; 869: 161149. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2022.161149.
33. Podgorski J, Berg M. Global analysis and prediction of fluoride in groundwater. Nat Commun. 2022; 13(1): 4232. doi: 10.1038/s41467-022-31940-x.
34. Strong GA. Liberty, religion and fluoridation. Santa Clara L Rev. 1967; 8(1): 37-58.
35. Newbrun E. The fluoridation war: a scientific dispute or a religious argument? J Public Health Dent. 1996; 56(5 Spec No): 246-252. doi: 10.1111/j.1752-7325.1996. tb02447.x.
36. Barnett-Rose R. Compulsory water fluoridation: justifiable public health benefit or human experimental research without informed consent? Wm Mary Envtl L Pol’y Rev. 2014; 39(1): 201-241.
37. Vinceti SR. COVID-19 compulsory vaccination and the European Court of Human Rights. Acta Biomed. 2021; 92(S6): e2021472. doi: 10.23750/abm.v92iS6.12333.
38. Petersen PE, Ogawa H. Prevention of dental caries through the use of fluoride--the WHO approach. Community Dent Health. 2016; 33(2): 66-68. doi: 10.1922/CDH_Petersen03.
39. Tarazona-Alvarez B, Lopez-Roldan A, Vidal-Infer A, Alonso-Arroyo A. Bibliometric study of the systematic reviews and meta-analyses in dentistry. J Clin Exp Dent. 2023; 15(11): e929-e937. doi: 10.4317/jced.60884.
40. Palandri L, Urbano T, Pezzuoli C, Miselli F, Caraffi R, Filippini T, et al. The key role of public health in renovating Italian biomedical doctoral programs. Ann Ig. 2024 Jan 17. doi. 10.7416/ai.2024.2592. Epub ahead of print.
41. Hung M, Mohajeri A, Chiang J, Park J, Bautista B, Hardy C, et al. Community water fluoridation in focus: a comprehensive look at fluoridation levels across America. Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2023; 20(23): 7100. doi: 10.3390/ijerph20237100.
42. US Department of Health, Human Services Federal Panel on Community Water Fluoridation. US Public Health Service recommendation for fluoride concentration in drinking water for the prevention of dental caries. Public Health Rep. 2015; 130(4): 318-331. doi: 10.1177/003335491513000408.
43. United States Environmental Protection Agency (US-EPA). EPA and HHS Announce New Scientific Assessments and Actions on Fluoride /Agencies working together to maintain benefits of preventing tooth decay while preventing excessive exposure; 2011. Available from: https://www.epa.gov/ archive/epapages/newsroom_archive/newsreleases/86964a f577c37ab285257811005a8417.html. [Last accessed: 2023 December 30].
44. Hoke K. State laws and regulations addressing fluoridation in water; 2020. Available from: https://www.networkforphl. org/resources/50-state-survey-state-laws-and-regulationsaddressing-fluoridation-in-water/. [Last accessed: 2023 December 30].
45. Clark MB, Keels MA, Slayton RL, Section on oral health. Fluoride use in caries prevention in the primary care setting. Pediatrics. 2020; 146(6): e2020034637. doi: 10.1542/ peds.2020-034637.
46. American Public Health Association (APHA). Community water fluoridation in the United States; 2008. Available from: https://www.apha.org/policies-and-advocacy/public-healthpolicy-statements/policy-database/2014/07/24/13/36/ community-water-fluoridation-in-the-united-states. [Last accessed: 2023 December 30].
47. Association of Metropolitan Water Agencies (AMWA). Judge rules EPA must review new evidence in fluoride case; 2023. Available from: https://www.amwa.net/article/ judge-rules-epa-must-review-new-evidence-fluoride-case. [Last accessed: 2023 December 30].
48. Goodwin M, Emsley R, Kelly MP, Sutton M, Tickle M, Walsh T, et al. Evaluation of water fluoridation scheme in Cumbria: the CATFISH prospective longitudinal cohort study. Southampton (UK): National Institute for Health and Care Research, 2022.
49. Goodwin M, Kelly M. Long in the tooth: is water fluoridation out of date? 2023. Available from: https://blog.policy. manchester.ac.uk/posts/2023/03/long-in-the-tooth-is-waterfluoridation-out-of-date/. [Last accessed: 2023 December 30].
50. Wordley V, Bedi R. A review of water fluoridation implementation strategy in England 2002-2005. BMC Oral Health. 2020; 20(1): 105. doi: 10.1186/s12903-020-01102-w.
51. UK Parliament. Water fluoridation and dental health; 2021. Available from: https://post.parliament.uk/water-fluoridation-and-dental-health/. [Last accessed: 2023 December 30].
52. Song Y, Kim J. Community water fluoridation: caveats to implement justice in public oral health. Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2021; 18(5): 2372. doi: 10.3390/ijerph18052372.
53. Vasantavada PV, Hearnshaw S, Do L, Vernazza CR, Zohoori F. Community water fluoridation. Comm Dental Health. 2021; 38(3): 158-160. doi: 10.1922/CDH_Sept21editorial03.
54. The Official Home of UK Legislation. Health and Care Act 2022; 2023. Available from: https://www.legislation.gov. uk/ukpga/2022/31/contents/enacted. [Last accessed: 2023 December 30].
55. Carducci AL, Agodi A, Ancona C, Angelini P, Bagordo F, Barbone F, et al. Impact of the environment on the health: From theory to practice. Environ Res. 2021; 194: 110517. doi: 10.1016/j.envres.2020.110517.
56. Sexton CT, Ha DH, Le T, Lalloo R, Ford P, Do LG, et al. Socio-economic status and access to fluoridated water in Queensland: an ecological data linkage study. Med J Aust. 2023. doi: 10.5694/mja2.52196.
57. Tobias G, Khaimov A, Zini A, Sgan-Cohen HD, Mann J, Chotiner Bar-Yehuda Y, et al. Caries prevalence and water fluoridation in Israel: a cross-sectionalstudy. Quintessence Int. 2023. doi: 10.3290/j.qi.b4790573.
58. Vinceti SR. Reorganizing Italy’s territorial healthcare: the Ministerial Decree No. 77/2022 and its comparative significance. Ann Ig. 2023; 35(3): 367-371. doi: 10.7416/ ai.2023.2556.
59. Morris AJ, Lowry R. Community water fluoridation: legislation and evidence base. Dent Update. 2023; 50(6): 479-481. doi: 10.12968/denu.2023.50.6.479.
60. Ahmad Dar FA, Kurella S. Fluoride in drinking water: an in-depth analysis of its prevalence, health effects, advances in detection and treatment. Mater Today Proc. 2024. doi: 10.1016/j.matpr.2023.05.645.
61. European Commission. Fluoridation; 2010. Available from: https://ec.europa.eu/health/scientific_committees/opinions_layman/fluoridation/en/l-3/1.htm#:~:text=The%20 concentration%20of%20fluoride%20in,and%201.5%20 mg%2FL). [Last accessed: 2023 December 30].
62. Gimenez-Forcada E, Luque-Espinar JA, Lopez-Bahut
MT, Grima-Olmedo J, Jimenez-Sanchez J, OntiverosBeltranena C, et al. Analysis of the geological control on the spatial distribution of potentially toxic concentrations of As and F(-) in groundwater on a Pan-European scale.
Ecotoxicol Environ Saf. 2022; 247: 114161. doi: 10.1016/j. ecoenv.2022.114161.
63. Cinti D, Vaselli O, Poncia PP, Brusca L, Grassa F, Procesi M, et al. Anomalous concentrations of arsenic, fluoride
and radon in volcanic-sedimentary aquifers from central Italy: quality indexes for management of the water resource. Environ Pollut. 2019; 253: 525-537. doi: 10.1016/j.
envpol.2019.07.063.
64. D’Alessandro W, Bellomo S, Parello F, Brusca L, Longo M. Survey on fluoride, bromide and chloride contents in public drinking water supplies in Sicily (Italy). Environ Monit Assess. 2008; 145(1-3): 303-313. doi: 10.1007/s10661-007 -0039-y.
65. Parrone D, Ghergo S, Frollini E, Rossi D, Preziosi E. Arsenic-fluoride co-contamination in groundwater: vackground and anomalies in a volcanic-sedimentary aquifer in central Italy. J Geochem Explor. 2020; 217: 106590. doi: 10.1016/j. gexplo.2020.106590.
66. Fuoco I, Apollaro C, Criscuoli A, De Rosa R, Velizarov S, Figoli A. Fluoride polluted groundwaters in Calabria region (Southern Italy): natural source and remediation. Water. 2021; 13(12): 1626. doi: 10.3390/w13121626.
67. Harkness JS, Jurgens BC. Effects of imported recharge on fluoride trends in groundwater used for public supply in California. Sci Total Environ. 2022; 830: 154782. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2022.154782.
68. European Commission. Directive (EU) 2020/2184 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 16 December 2020 on the quality of water intended for human consumption; 2021. Available from: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/ dir/2020/2184/oj. [Last accessed: 2023 December 30].
69. Petrini C. La fluorazione delle acque in Italia: Istituto Superiore di Sanità - EpiCentro; 2023. Available from: https:// www.epicentro.iss.it/cavo_orale/nota. [Last accessed: 2023, December 30].
70. Saad H, Escoube R, Babajko S, Houari S. Fluoride intake through dental care products: a systematic review. Front Oral Health. 2022; 3: 916372. doi: 10.3389/froh.2022.916372.
71. World Population Review. Water fluoridation by country 2023; 2023. Available from: https://worldpopulationreview. com/country-rankings/water-fluoridation-by-country. [Last accessed: 2023 December 30].
72. Sweeney MR, Kosego S, Reilly A. Fluoridation policy and practice: a European story separating myths from reality: School of Nursing and Human Sciences; 2023. Available from: https://doras.dcu.ie/23339/3/Fluoride%20Report.pdf. [Last accessed: 2023 December 30].
73. Azara A, Castiglia P, Piana A, Masia MD, Palmieri A, Arru B, et al. Derogation from drinking water quality standards in Italy according to the European Directive 98/83/EC and the Legislative Decree 31/2001 - a look at the recent past. Ann Ig. 2018; 30(6): 517-526. doi: 10.7416/ai.2018.2252.
74. Zicari G, Marro S, Soardo V, Berruti R, Maggi C, Cerrato E, et al. The history of derogations from chemical parametric values set by the European Drinking Water Directive (Council Directive 98/83/EC), in Italy and the Piedmont region. Ig Sanita Pubbl. 2014; 70(3): 323-338.
75. The Irish Expert Body on Fluorides and Health. Position statement from the Irish expert body on fluorides and health
regarding water fluoridation in the Republic of Ireland; 76. Garcia Rincon LJ, Frazao P. Public policies for fluoride use 2023. Available from: https://www.fluoridesandhealth.ie/ in Colombia and Brazil before and during the adoption of assets/files/pdf/position_statement_on_water_fluoridation. the right to health. Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2023; pdf. [Last accessed: 2023 December 30]. 20(3): 2058. doi: 10.3390/ijerph20032058.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Silvio Roberto Vinceti, Federica Veneri, Tommaso Filippini (Author)
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0) which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Transfer of Copyright and Permission to Reproduce Parts of Published Papers.
Authors retain the copyright for their published work. No formal permission will be required to reproduce parts (tables or illustrations) of published papers, provided the source is quoted appropriately and reproduction has no commercial intent. Reproductions with commercial intent will require written permission and payment of royalties.