Assessment of the healthcare managerial skills offered by the Italian post-graduate schools of public health
Keywords:
Public health, training programs, formation, health managementAbstract
Background. The Italian National Health Service (Servizio Sanitario Nazionale, SSN) is facing relevant challenges due to decreased financing and increased healthcare costs (1). In this complex framework, most of the Italian Medical Doctors, after obtaining their Specialization degree in Public Health, develop their careers in organizational and managerial roles in public and private health organizations, i.e. hospitals, local health units, health districts or national and international agencies (1, 2). Public health technical competencies, in particular policy and management, are of crucial importance to develop, run and support healthcare services. However, some gaps exist between current public health needs and the extent to which Public Health Residents are trained in the above fields (3, 4).
Study design. The study is a cross-sectional cognitive survey carried out through a questionnaire sent by e-mail to Residents and Directors of the Italian Schools of Public Health, from May to November 2018. The questionnaire was sent only to the accredited Schools which had all four years of the course running. Methods. The questionnaire investigated 35 managerial topics divided into 4 macro-areas. It was sent to both Directors of the SPHs and the Residents of 32 Schools. The latter were asked to provide a single collective answer per School. Respondents could assign a score from 1 (topic not addressed at all) to 4 (topic addressed extensively and linked to other related topics) to each item, also taking into account the skills acquired through internships, seminars, etc. that involved all the Residents.
Results. Answers were received from the Residents of 30/32 (93.8%) SPHs and from 15/32 (46.9%) of the Directors. Scores given by the Directors were higher than the ones of the Residents for every topic, and for 17 out of 35 items (48.6%) a statistically significant difference has been obtained. In the overall score of 3 macro-areas out of 4 (General issues, Managerial tools and macro-organisational Models) there are statistically significant differences. In Soft skills macro-area, the single scores of all topics are generally low for both Directors and Residents.
Conclusion. The study shows that the Residents declare a strong need for training improvement in the field pf healthcare organization and management: the median score is equal to or greater than 3 (topic addressed extensively) in only a few answers. The comparison between Directors’ and Residents’ scores highlights a different perception of the training offered in these areas. The study results could be pivotal for the improvement of the managerial skills provided to the Residents in Public Health of the Country.
References
1. Odone A, Privitera GP, Signorelli C. Postgraduate medical education in public health: The case of Italy and a call for action. Public Health Rev 2017; 38(1): 1-8.
2. Soncini F, Odone A, Lalic T, et al. [Employment opportunities and job satisfaction in the field of Public Health: a survey among recent graduates of the Hygiene and Preventive Medicine residency in Italy]. Ig Sanita Pubbl 2017; 73(6): 567-77.
3. Berkenbosch L, Schoenmaker SG, Ahern S, et al. Medical residents’ perceptions of their competencies and training needs in health care management: An international comparison. BMC Med Educ 2013; 13(1): 25.
4. D’Andrea E, Lucaroni F, Parente P, et al. Quali le competenze per il professionista medico di sanità pubblica oggi? Analisi, considerazioni e risultati formazione condivisa tra le Scuole mediche in Igiene e Medicina Preventiva di Roma. Ig Sanita Pubbl 2016; 72(2): 107-17.
5. Peik SM, Mohan KM, Baba T, Donadel M, Labruto A, Loh LC. Comparison of public health and preventive medicine physician specialty training in six countries: Identifying challenges and opportunities. Med Teach 2016; 38(11): 1146-51.
6. Decreto Ministeriale 4 febbraio 2015, n. 68. Riordino delle scuole di specializzazione di area sanitaria. GU Ser Gen n. 126 del 03-06-2015 (Suppl Ord n. 25).
7. Decreto Ministeriale 1 agosto 2005. Riassetto Scuole di Specializzazione di Area Sanitaria. GU Ser Gen del 5 novembre 2005 n. 285 (Suppl Ord n. 176). Available on: http://attiministeriali. miur.it/anno-2005/agosto/dm-01082005.aspx [Last accessed: 2020, Mar 26].
8. Franchino G, Di Gregori V, Ricciardi A, Al E. Know-how ed aspettative formative in termini di medical management tra le scuole di specializzazione di igiene e medicina preventiva italiane. Presented at 5° Congresso Nazionale Società Italiana Medici Manager; 2012, Jun 14-15, Rome.
9. Costantino C, Cinquetti S, Garavelli E, et al. [The key role of public health medical resident education for future public health challenges]. Epidemiol Prev 2014; 38(6): 115-9.
10. Garavelli E, Marcantoni C, Costantino C, et al. Education and training among Italian postgraduate medical schools in public health: a comparative analysis. Ann Ig 2014; 26(5): 426-34.
11. Taietti D, Tirani M, Shahi E, et al. Survey on professional training in three Italian Post-Graduate Schools of Public Health. Ann Ig 2015; 27(4): 623-32.
12. Fara G, Nardi G, Signorelli C, Fanti M. Employment opportunities and education needs of physicians with specialty training in Hygiene and Preventive Medicine. Ig Sanita Pubbl 2005; 61(6): 617-26.
13. Bertoncello C, Buja A, Silenzi A, et al. Good governance competencies in public health to train public health physicians. Int J Public Health 2015; 60(6): 737-49.
14. Decreto Interministeriale 28 febbraio 2019. Proroga del termine di cui all’articolo 8, comma 2 del decreto 13 giugno 2017, recante: «Standard, requisiti e indicatori di attività formativa e assistenziale delle Scuole di specializzazione di area sanitaria». GU Ser Gen n. 68 del 21-03-2019.
15. Decreto Legislativo 4 agosto 2016, n. 171. Attuazione della delega di cui all’articolo 11, comma 1, lettera p), della legge 7 agosto 2015, n. 124, in materia di dirigenza sanitaria. GU Ser Gen n. 206 del 03-09-2016.
16. Decreto Legislativo 19 giugno 1999, n. 229. Norme per la razionalizzazione del Servizio sanitario nazionale, a norma dell’articolo 1 della legge 30 novembre 1998, n. 419. GU Ser Gen n.165 del 16-07-1999 (Suppl Ord n. 132).
17. Decreto Legislativo 30 dicembre 1992, n. 502. Riordino della disciplina in materia sanitaria, a norma dell’articolo 1 della legge 23 ottobre 1992, n. 421. GU Ser Gen n. 305 del 30-12-1992 (Suppl Ord n. 137).
18. Bando per l’ammissione alle Scuole di specializzazione in Medicina A.A. 2013/14. Decreto Ministeriale 8 agosto 2014, n. 612. Bando per l’ammissione alle Scuole di specializzazione in Medicina a.a. 2013/14. GU 4a Ser speciale del 29-08-2014, n. 67. Available on: http://attiministeriali.miur.it/anno-2014/agosto/dm-08082014. aspx [Last accessed: 2020, Mar 26].
19. Bando per l’ammissione dei medici alle scuole di specializzazione di area sanitaria A.A. 2014/2015 (D.M. n. 315/2015) coordinato con le rettifiche introdotte dal D.M. n. 321/2015. Decreto Ministeriale 26 maggio 2015, n. 315. Rettifiche al bando per l’ammissione dei medici alle scuole di specializzazione di area sanitaria per l’aa. 2014-2015. GU Ser Gen del 01-062015, n. 125. Available on: http://attiministeriali. miur.it/anno-2015/maggio/dm-26052015.aspx [Last accessed: 2020, Mar 26].
20. Bando per l’ammissione dei medici alle Scuole di specializzazione di area sanitaria A.A. 2015/2016. Decreto Ministeriale 20 maggio 2016, n. 313. Avviso relativo al Bando per l’accesso dei medici alle scuole di specializzazione A.A. 2015/2016. GU Ser Gen n. 117 del 20-052016. Available on: http://attiministeriali.miur. it/anno-2016/maggio/dm-20052016.aspx [Last accessed: 2020, Mar 26].
21. Bando per l’ammissione dei medici alle Scuole di specializzazione di area sanitaria A.A. 20162017. Decreto Ministeriale 29 settembre 2017, n. 720. Avviso relativo al bando per l’ammissione dei medici alle Scuole di specializzazione di area sanitaria, per l’a.a. 2016/2017. GU Ser Gen n. 228 del 29-09-2017 e Successive rettifiche. GU Ser Gen n. 233 del 05-10-2017. Available
on: https://www.miur.gov.it/web/guest/-/d-mdi-rettifica-del-bando-ssm-2016-2017 [Last accessed: 2020, Mar 26].
22. Decreto Interministeriale 13 giugno 2017. Standard, requisiti e indicatori di attività formativa e assistenziale delle Scuole di specializzazione di area sanitaria. GU Ser Gen n. 163 del 14-072017 (Suppl Ord n. 38).
23. Rossi D, Bizzarro A, Affanni P, Pasquarella C, Odone A, Signorelli C. The educational background of the Top Managers of the Italian Health Authorities: Results of a study on eight Regions. Acta Biomed 2019; 90(9): 87-91.
24. Odone A, Bossi E, Gaeta M, et al. Risk Management in healthcare: Results from a national-level survey and scientometric analysis in Italy. Acta Biomed 2019; 90(9): 76-86.
25. Mazzucco W, Silenzi A, Gray M, Vettor R. The accreditation system of Italian medical residency programs: Fostering quality and sustainability of the national health service. Acta Biomed 2019; 90(9): 15-20.
26. Directive 2005/36/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 7 September 2005 on the recognition of professional qualifications. (OJ L 255 30.9.2005, p. 22).
27. Foldspang A. From Potential to Action Public Health Core Competences For Essential Public Health Operations. Anders Foldspang and The Association of Schools of Public Health in the European Region, 2016; 2.
28. World Health Organisation (WHO) - Regional Office for Europe. European Action Plan for Strengthening Public Health Capacities and Services. Regional Committee for Europe, Sixty-second session. 2012: 1-42. Available on: http://www.euro.who.int/__data/assets/ pdf_file/0005/171770/RC62wd12rev1-Eng. pdf?ua=1%0Ahttp://www.euro.who.int/en/ who-we-are/governance [Last accessed: 2020, Mar 26].
29. Stein DH, Salive ME. Adequacy of training in preventive medicine and public health. Acad Med 1996; 71(4): 375-80.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0) which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Transfer of Copyright and Permission to Reproduce Parts of Published Papers.
Authors retain the copyright for their published work. No formal permission will be required to reproduce parts (tables or illustrations) of published papers, provided the source is quoted appropriately and reproduction has no commercial intent. Reproductions with commercial intent will require written permission and payment of royalties.