End-of-life in the operational functioning of public healthcare: ethical and legal issues
Main Article Content
end-of-life ethics, medical assistance in dying, ethical decision-making, euthanasia
Background and aim: The article aims to outline the current scenario relative to the medical role in end-of-life issues. In order to do this, historical-legal references have been drawn upon relating to technical, legal and scientific thought and doctrine, as it has come down to us in the medical field through the evolution of ethical and philosophical frameworks. Methods: The authors have conducted a thorough analysis of end-of-life legislative initiatives, in Italy and across the EU, and court rulings to outline possible ways to harmonize and reconcile the current medical ethics frameworks with the needs and rights of all, especially the most vulnerable among us. To that end, the necessary operational choices and adjustments have not yet been made by our legal system, from a technical, as well as moral, standpoint. Results: An operational proposal has therefore been laid out to protect both healthcare providers and patients, in a relationship that goes beyond treatment in the strict sense, which prioritizes mutual needs as an integral part of a common, essential path.Conclusions: In order for doctors to consider themselves complete, they should in fact deal not only with life, but also with death.
2.The Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Dignity of the Human Being with regard to the Application of Biology and Medicine. Signed on 4th April 1997. Came into force on 1st December 1999. Available online: https://rm.coe.int/168007cf98 (Accessed on 3rd January 2023).
3.Universal Declaration of Human Rights. Proclaimed by the United Nations General Assembly in Paris on 10th December 1948. Available online: https://www.un.org/en/about-us/universal-declaration-of-human-rights (Accessed on 3rd January 2023).
4.Dolci M, Favero C, Toumi W, Favi E, Tarantini L, Signorini L, Basile G, Bollati V, D'Alessandro S, Bagnoli P, Ferrante P, Delbue S. Human Endogenous Retroviruses Long Terminal Repeat Methylation, Transcription, and Protein Expression in Human Colon Cancer. Front Oncol. 2020 Oct 27;10:569015. doi: 10.3389/fonc.2020.569015.
5.Monaco AP. Joseph Edward Murray, M.D., 1919-2012: pioneering transplant and reconstructive plastic surgeon and scientist, nobel Laureate, humanitarian-an appreciation. Transplantation. 2013 Apr 15;95(7):903-907. doi: 10.1097/TP.0b013e3182895cf2.
6.Signorini L, Dolci M, Favi E, et al. Viral Genomic Characterization and Replication Pattern of Human Polyomaviruses in Kidney Transplant Recipients. Viruses. 2020 Nov 9;12(11):1280. doi: 10.3390/v12111280.
7.Montanari Vergallo G, Busardò FP, Zaami S, Marinelli E. The static evolution of the new Italian code of medical ethics. Eur Rev Med Pharmacol Sci. 2016;20(3):575-880.
8.Petrini C. After the Italian Constitutional Court's ruling on the absence of criminal liability for assisted suicide: the role of ethics committees and clinical ethics. Editorial. Ann Ist Super Sanita. 2019 Oct-Dec;55(4):311-313. doi: 10.4415/ANN_19_04_01.
9.Marinelli E, Busardò FP. Assisted suicide: article 17 of the Italian Code of Medical Ethics follows in the footsteps of the Italian Constitutional Court's landmark ruling. Eur Rev Med Pharmacol Sci. 2020 Oct;24(20):10309-10312. doi: 10.26355/eurrev_202010_23376.
10.Montanari Vergallo G, Zaami S, Bruti V, Signore F, Marinelli E. How the Legislation on Medically Assisted Procreation Has Evolved in Italy. Med Law. 2017;36(2): 5-28.
11.Rallo G, Negro F, Consalvo F, Piersanti V, Marinelli S. Medically assisted procreation in times of COVID-19: what impact on health care system organization and the reproductive rights of couples? Acta Biomed. 2021 Nov 3;92(5):e2021275. doi: 10.23750/abm.v92i5.11900.
12.Cippitani R. Ethical issues and law-making power: how European case law has rewritten Italian law on medically assisted reproduction. Monash Bioeth Rev. 2019 Oct;37(1-2):46-67. doi: 10.1007/s40592-018-0088-8.
13.Malvasi A, Zaami S, Tinelli A, Trojano G, Montanari Vergallo G, Marinelli E. Kristeller maneuvers or fundal pressure and maternal/neonatal morbidity: obstetric and judicial literature review. J Matern Fetal Neonatal Med. 2019 Aug;32(15):2598-2607. doi: 10.1080/14767058.2018.1441278.
14.Marinelli S, Cucinella G, Basile G. COVID-19 and female fertility: the flaws of Italian Law 40/2004 on assisted procreation in pandemic times. Acta Biomed. 2022 Oct 26;93(5):e2022316. doi: 10.23750/abm.v93i5.13765.
15.Gruppo di Lavoro in Materia di Aiuto Medico al Morire. Aiuto medico a morire e diritto: per la costruzione di un dibattito pubblico plurale e consapevole [Medical assistence to die, and law.]. Recenti Prog Med. 2019 Oct;110(10):462-472. Italian. doi: 10.1701/3246.32161.
16.Veronesi U. Il diritto di morire: la libertà del laico di fronte alla sofferenza. Mondadori, 2005, p.25.
17.Veshi D, Koka E, Venditti C. A New Law of Advance Directives in Italy: A Critical Legal Analysis. J Law Med. 2019 Apr;26(3):702-710.
18.van der Arend AJ. An ethical perspective on euthanasia and assisted suicide in The Netherlands from a nursing point of view. Nurs Ethics. 1998 Jul;5(4):307-318. doi: 10.1177/096973309800500404.
19.Mangino DR, Nicolini ME, De Vries RG, Kim SYH. Euthanasia and Assisted Suicide of Persons With Dementia in the Netherlands. Am J Geriatr Psychiatry. 2020 Apr;28(4):466-477. doi: 10.1016/j.jagp.2019.08.015.
20.Montanari Vergallo G, Busardò FP, Berretta P, Marinelli E, Zaami S. Advance healthcare directives: moving towards a universally recognized right. Eur Rev Med Pharmacol Sci. 2018 May;22(10):2915-2916. doi: 10.26355/eurrev_201805_15043.
21.Van Nieuwenhove M, Ricou B. Euthanasie et suicide assisté - Vision comparative et réflexive entre la Belgique et la Suisse [Euthanasia and assisted suicide - Comparative and reflexive vision between Belgium and Switzerland]. Rev Med Suisse. 2021 Apr 7;17(733):708-711. French.
22.Nanner H. The effect of assisted dying on suicidality: a synthetic control analysis of population suicide rates in Belgium. J Public Health Policy. 2021 Mar;42(1):86-97. doi: 10.1057/s41271-020-00249-8.
23.McEvoy P. Euthanasia, ethics, and the Gordian Knot: is the Hippocratic Code obsolete? Br J Gen Pract. 2015 Dec;65(641):624-5. doi: 10.3399/bjgp15X687721.
24.Euthanasia in Belgium, the Netherlands and Luxembourg. Prescrire Int. 2013 Nov;22(143):274-278.
25.Velasco Bernal C, Trejo-Gabriel-Galan JM. Leyes de eutanasia en España y en el mundo: aspectos médicos [Euthanasia laws in Spain and in the world: Medical aspects]. Aten Primaria. 2022 Jan;54(1):102170. Spanish. doi: 10.1016/j.aprim.2021.102170.
26.Bernal-Carcelén I. Euthanasia: trends and opinions in Spain. Rev Esp Sanid Penit. 2020 Sep-Dec;22(3):112-115. doi: 10.18176/resp.00020.
27.Hyde R. Germany overturns ban on assisted suicide. Lancet. 2020 Mar 7;395(10226):774. doi: 10.1016/S0140-6736(20)30533-X. Erratum in: Lancet. 2020 Mar 28;395(10229):1038.
28.Mroz S, Dierickx S, Deliens L, Cohen J, Chambaere K. Assisted dying around the world: a status quaestionis. Ann Palliat Med. 2021 Mar;10(3):3540-3553. doi: 10.21037/apm-20-637.
29.Burkhardt S, La Harpe R. Debates about assisted suicide in Switzerland. Am J Forensic Med Pathol. 2012 Dec;33(4):410-413. doi: 10.1097/PAF.0b013e318273b83f.
30.Sprung CL, Somerville MA, Radbruch L, et al. Physician-Assisted Suicide and Euthanasia: Emerging Issues From a Global Perspective. J Palliat Care 2018; 33: 197-203.
31.Vyssoki B, Stich M, Eder-Pissarek E, et al. Angekündigter assistierter Suizid in der Schweiz – Ein Fallbericht [Announced assisted suicide in Switzerland: a case report]. Neuropsychiatr. 2021 Dec;35(4):187-191. German. doi: 10.1007/s40211-021-00398-6.
32.Emanuel EJ, Onwuteaka-Philipsen BD, Urwin JW, Cohen J. Attitudes and Practices of Euthanasia and Physician-Assisted Suicide in the United States, Canada, and Europe. JAMA. 2016 Jul 5;316(1):79-90. doi: 10.1001/jama.2016.8499. Erratum in: JAMA. 2016 Sep 27;316(12):1319.
33.Barranha R. Existe um Papel para a Psiquiatria no Processo de Morte Assistida em Portugal? [Is There a Role for Psychiatry in Physician-Assisted Death in Portugal?]. Acta Med Port. 2020 Sep 1;33(9):629. Portuguese. doi: 10.20344/amp.14443.
34.Julião M. Letter to the Editor Regarding Barranha´s Paper: "Is There a Role for Psychiatry in Physician-Assisted Death in Portugal?". Acta Med Port. 2020 Nov 2;33(11):779. doi: 10.20344/amp.14853.
35.Aubry R. End-of-life, euthanasia, and assisted suicide: An update on the situation in France. Rev Neurol (Paris). 2016 Dec;172(12):719-724. doi: 10.1016/j.neurol.2016.09.007.
36.Boulanger A, Chabal T, Fichaux M, et al. Opinions about the new law on end-of-life issues in a sample of french patients receiving palliative care. BMC Palliat Care. 2017 Jan 21;16(1):7. doi: 10.1186/s12904-016-0174-8.
37.Italian Civil Code. Article 5. Atti di disposizione del proprio corpo. Codified by Law n. 235, enacted on 3rd April 1957. Available online: https://www.codice-civile-online.it/codice-civile/articolo-5-del-codice-civile (Accessed on 3rd January 2023).
38.Italian Criminal Code. Title XII – Dei delitti contro la persona, articles 575-623. Available online: https://www.ilcodicepenale.it/#Titolo_XII_-_Dei_delitti_contro_la_persona_artt_575-623 (Accessed on 3rd January 2023).
39.Law no. 219/2017. Norme in materia di consenso informato e di disposizioni anticipate di trattamento. Enacted on 22nd December 2017. Available online: https://www.gazzettaufficiale.it/eli/id/2018/1/16/18G00006/sg (Accessed on 3rd January 2023).
40.Cioffi A, Zaami S. Italian Law no. 219/2017: consequences on the informed consent of the psychiatric patient and on the therapeutic privilege. Riv Psichiatr. 2020 Mar-Apr;55(2):129-130. doi: 10.1708/3333.33028.
41.Montanari Vergallo G, Gulino M, Bersani G, Rinaldi R. Euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide for patients with depression: thought-provoking remarks. Riv Psichiatr. 2020 Mar-Apr;55(2):119-128. doi: 10.1708/3333.33027.
42.Italian Criminal Code. Art. 580. Available online: https://testolegge.com/codice-penale/articolo-580 (Accessed on 3rd January 2023).
43.Supreme Court of Cassation, ruling n. 31476, issued on 6th February 1998.
44.Constitutional Court Ordinance n. 207/2018. Issued on 24th October 2018. Available online: https://www.cortecostituzionale.it/actionSchedaPronuncia.do?anno=2018&numero=207 (Accessed on 3rd January 2023).
45.Constitutional Court Ruling n.242/2019. Issued on 25th September 2019. Available online: https://cortecostituzionale.it/actionSchedaPronuncia.do?anno=2019&numero=242 (Accessed on 3rd January 2023).
46.European Convention on Human Rights. Signed 4 November 1950. Came into force on 3rd September 1953. Available online: https://www.echr.coe.int/Documents/Convention_ENG.pdf (Accessed on 3rd January 2023).
47.Paterlini M. Paraplegic man is first person to be allowed to die by assisted suicide in Italy. BMJ. 2021 Nov 26;375:n2927. doi: 10.1136/bmj.n2927.
48.Constitution of the Italian Republic. Enacted on 27th December 1947. Available online: https://www.senato.it/sites/default/files/media-documents/COST_INGLESE.pdf (Accessed on 3rd January 2023).
49.Petrini C. Will medically-assisted suicide mean the rebirth of (clinical) ethics committees in Italy? Med Leg J. 2020 Nov;88(1_suppl):26-30. doi: 10.1177/0025817220923650.
50.Delbon P, Maghin F, Conti A. Medically assisted suicide in Italy: the recent judgment of the Constitutional Court. Clin Ter. 2021 May 5;172(3):193-196. doi: 10.7417/CT.2021.2312.
51.Ricci G, Gibelli F, Sirignano A. Editorial - From ruling No. 242/2019 of the Constitutional Court to the Italian law on medically assisted death: a complex transition. Eur Rev Med Pharmacol Sci. 2022 Jul;26(13):4546-4549. doi: 10.26355/eurrev_202207_29174.
52.Constitutional Court Ruling 242, issued on 22nd November 2019. Available online: https://sentenze.laleggepertutti.it/sentenza/corte-costituzionale-n-242-del-22-11-2019 (Accessed on 3rd January 2023).
53.Busardò FP, Bello S, Gulino M, Zaami S, Frati P. Advance health care directives and "public guardian": the Italian supreme court requests the status of current and not future inability. Biomed Res Int. 2014;2014:576391. doi: 10.1155/2014/576391.
54.d’Avack L. L’aiuto al suicidio medicalizzato sotto il controllo della Corte Costituzionale. Biodiritto. Issued in September 2019. Available online: https://www.biodiritto.org/content/download/3926/46251/version/1/file/d%27avack.pdf (Accessed on 3rd January 2023).
55.Draft Bill titled “Morte volontaria medicalmente assistita”. Passed by the Italian Chamber of Deputies on 10th March 2022. Available online: https://temi.camera.it/leg18/temi/morte-medicalmente-assistita.html (Accessed on 20th January 2023).
56.Morrell KM, Chavkin W. Conscientious objection to abortion and reproductive healthcare: a review of recent literature and implications for adolescents. Curr Opin Obstet Gynecol. 2015 Oct;27(5):333-338. doi: 10.1097/GCO.0000000000000196.
57.Montanari Vergallo G, Zaami S, Di Luca NM, Marinelli E. The conscientious objection: debate on emergency contraception. Clin Ter. 2017 Mar-Apr;168(2):e113-e119. doi: 10.7417/CT.2017.1991.
58.Zampas C. Legal and ethical standards for protecting women's human rights and the practice of conscientious objection in reproductive healthcare settings. Int J Gynaecol Obstet. 2013 Dec;123 Suppl 3:S63-S65. doi: 10.1016/S0020-7292(13)60005-3.
59.Zaami S, Signore F, Baffa A, Votino R, Marinelli E, Del Rio A. Emergency contraception: unresolved clinical, ethical and legal quandaries still linger. Panminerva Med. 2021 Mar;63(1):75-85. doi: 10.23736/S0031-0808.20.03921-X.